All times shown are Eastern Time (GMT-5:00) | Home -> Forums -> Lottery News -> Florida Lottery won't pay $500,000 winner, called 'misprint' Florida Lottery won't pay $500,000 winner, called 'misprint'Previous TopicNext Topicmid-Ohio United States Member #9 March 24, 2001 13458 Posts Offline | | Posted: May 20, 2007, 6:42 pm - IP Logged | |
"Looks like this guy is going to have follow the rules same as any other players if he expects to collect anything." Everything we have heard so far has been from the ticket holder and his wife. They probably took the ticket to a gas station, had it scanned, were told it wasn't a winner, showed the clerk the "1" on the top row, the cherk showed them the "th" and were told by the clerk it was a misprint. In the CNN interview the man and his wife both made it a point to mention several times they should be paid because the "1" on the prize row matched the "1" on top row. In a close up he pointed to the "1" on the top while his finger conviently covered the "th" below. I've never cashed a $500,000 winner, but everytime I've cashed a free ticket, I hand the ticket to the clerk, they scan it, pay me, and keep the ticket. According to the statement by the Florida Lottery, they have never seen the actual ticket. Should they take his word and write a check or is the Florida Lottery being unreasonable by asking to see the ticket? Sounds like this guy is trying to pull what that Ohio women Elecia Battle tried back in January of 2004 when she reported her misfortune of losing a lottery ticket worth $162M to the local police and newspapers before going to the lottery office to make a claim. When the real winner, Rebecca Jemison turned in the winning ticket, some thought she should have shared it with Elecia because she told such a convincing sob story and other thought Elecia should had gone to jail for filing a false report.. * THat which happens most * * is most likely to happen again * 
| | |
mid-Ohio United States Member #9 March 24, 2001 13458 Posts Offline | | Posted: May 20, 2007, 10:39 pm - IP Logged | |
"Looks like this guy is going to have follow the rules same as any other players if he expects to collect anything." Everything we have heard so far has been from the ticket holder and his wife. They probably took the ticket to a gas station, had it scanned, were told it wasn't a winner, showed the clerk the "1" on the top row, the cherk showed them the "th" and were told by the clerk it was a misprint. In the CNN interview the man and his wife both made it a point to mention several times they should be paid because the "1" on the prize row matched the "1" on top row. In a close up he pointed to the "1" on the top while his finger conviently covered the "th" below. I've never cashed a $500,000 winner, but everytime I've cashed a free ticket, I hand the ticket to the clerk, they scan it, pay me, and keep the ticket. According to the statement by the Florida Lottery, they have never seen the actual ticket. Should they take his word and write a check or is the Florida Lottery being unreasonable by asking to see the ticket? Should they take his word and write a check or is the Florida Lottery being unreasonable by asking to see the ticket? Wouldn't it be nice if lotteries accepted letters from players that read: Sir, Your terminal has made a big mistake, I bought a $20 ticket which I think is worth $500,000 and it does not agree. I have discussed this with my wife and a reporter from CNN, both which I trust completely and they think you should send me a check for a half million dollars. I await your check after which I will send you the ticket for inspection and verification. If I don't hear from you soon, I will seek the advice of a lawyer. Thank you. * THat which happens most * * is most likely to happen again * 
| | |
Miss Kitty georgia United States Member #14 November 9, 2001 21824 Posts Offline | | Posted: May 20, 2007, 11:13 pm - IP Logged | |
Should they take his word and write a check or is the Florida Lottery being unreasonable by asking to see the ticket? Wouldn't it be nice if lotteries accepted letters from players that read: Sir, Your terminal has made a big mistake, I bought a $20 ticket which I think is worth $500,000 and it does not agree. I have discussed this with my wife and a reporter from CNN, both which I trust completely and they think you should send me a check for a half million dollars. I await your check after which I will send you the ticket for inspection and verification. If I don't hear from you soon, I will seek the advice of a lawyer. Thank you. 
love to nibble those micey feet. | | |
Wandering Aimlessly United States Member #25708 November 5, 2005 4403 Posts Offline | | Posted: May 20, 2007, 11:55 pm - IP Logged | |
If this guy hands over the ticket and walks away expecting to hear from them, a week will go by without hearing from them, he'll call them up to see what's going on, and all the FL lottery is going to say "You never gave us the ticket". Guru, I doubt if this would ever happen. There isn't a big conspiracy going on here. Also this story has already gotten so much publicity, it would only be in their best interest to pay the claim if it's a legitimate ticket. | | |
United States Member #5437 June 30, 2004 21911 Posts Offline | | Posted: May 21, 2007, 12:26 am - IP Logged | |
(1) This happened in Florida (2) They are asking a prospective winner to hand the ticket to State employees for verification. (3) Are these the same people who counted the votes in Palm Beach County in 2000? LOL Are these the same people who counted the votes in Palm Beach County in 2000? LOL You cracked me up here.. lol | | |
GA United States Member #33980 February 22, 2006 1024 Posts Offline | | Posted: May 21, 2007, 1:30 am - IP Logged | |
If this guy hands over the ticket and walks away expecting to hear from them, a week will go by without hearing from them, he'll call them up to see what's going on, and all the FL lottery is going to say "You never gave us the ticket". Guru, I doubt if this would ever happen. There isn't a big conspiracy going on here. Also this story has already gotten so much publicity, it would only be in their best interest to pay the claim if it's a legitimate ticket. I agree with you Guru. If they cannot investigate without the ticket or with me standing right there than I don't trust it. It's like all you need is the barcode number anyway. | | |
Florida United States Member #23357 October 6, 2005 178 Posts Offline | | Posted: May 22, 2007, 11:23 am - IP Logged | |
Official announcement by the Florida Lottery:
"STATEMENT BY THE FLORIDA LOTTERY REGARDING POSSIBLE MISPRINT OF GOLD RUSH TICKET
TALLAHASSEE -- On Monday, May 14, the Florida Lottery learned of a possible printing error on a Florida Lottery GOLD RUSH Scratch-Off ticket. The Florida Lottery is investigating the circumstances of the apparent misprint; however, without possession of the original ticket in question, the Lottery¿s investigation is limited. While preliminary analysis of a photocopy of the ticket seems to indicate that it is a non-winning ticket, a final determination cannot be reached until the player submits a formal claim along with the original ticket.
To safeguard the integrity of Florida Lottery games and to ensure that all valid claims are paid, the Lottery subscribes to standard procedures that must be followed by all persons claiming a prize. These procedures are in place to benefit and protect all of our customers.
Last year alone, the Lottery's instant ticket vendor, Scientific Games, printed well over 500 million Florida Lottery Scratch-Off tickets. While the very nature of any mechanical printing process can never guarantee one hundred percent accuracy - whether you are speaking of newspapers or currency - similar incidents are extremely rare. However, in anticipation of these rare occurrences, the Lottery and its vendor have adopted redundant validation methods to properly identify winning tickets and avoid misprints. In an abundance of caution, the Lottery has also undertaken an immediate and comprehensive review to ensure the continued integrity of our games and confidence of the playing public.
We are extremely proud of our record of paying every valid claim for all winning tickets the Lottery has produced in its 19-year history. In fact, the very foundation of the Lottery's ability to raise funds for education rests solely on the trust our players have in playing our games. To ensure fairness and equity for all players, the Lottery must ensure that the established rules are followed and that prizes are paid only on legitimate winning tickets. That trust is based on two principles: first, that all lottery profits go to education; and, second, that all prize claims are paid for every valid winning ticket."
http://flalottery.com/inet/currentNewsContent.do?searchID=194023 | | |
United States Member #4963 May 30, 2004 3230 Posts Offline | | Posted: May 22, 2007, 12:15 pm - IP Logged | |
| | |
NY United States Member #24178 October 16, 2005 2127 Posts Offline | | Posted: May 22, 2007, 6:40 pm - IP Logged | |
I must have been lucky because the company I worked for before I retired alway paid the regular salary of employees who serve the community. They wouldn't pay for any overtime opportunity missed. We had people looking for ways to serve the community on company time for the extra pay, even people who worked nights got paid if they were too tire to come to work after serving the community doing the day. I only used the system once and that was when I drove 100 miles to Akron to serve on a Federal jury. I've voted in every election and have never been asked to serve on a local jury and now that I'm retired I hope that doesn't change. In some places your employer is required to pay you your regular salary while serving jury duty if the company has some minimum number of employees. If your company paid people for doing volunteer work they were unusually generous. | | |
mid-Ohio United States Member #9 March 24, 2001 13458 Posts Offline | | Posted: May 23, 2007, 3:26 pm - IP Logged | |
http://www.ocala.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20070516/NEWS/205160332/1025/news Annemarie Curcio said they were robbed. "My husband gave them a real $20 bill and they gave him a fake ticket," Apparently Mrs. Curcio hasn't bought a lot of lottery tickets if she thinks a $20 lottery tickets that wins nothing is fake. * THat which happens most * * is most likely to happen again * 
| | |
United States Member #53025 May 29, 2007 55 Posts Offline | | Posted: June 2, 2007, 12:40 am - IP Logged | |
Either pay the man and his wife or get out the lottery buiness, End Of story!!  | | |
Coastal Georgia United States Member #2703 October 30, 2003 1867 Posts Offline | | Posted: June 6, 2007, 5:39 pm - IP Logged | |
Have their been any new developments on this story since it broke, does anyone know ? | | |
Kentucky United States Member #33045 February 14, 2006 2812 Posts Offline | | Posted: June 7, 2007, 2:37 pm - IP Logged | |
Have their been any new developments on this story since it broke, does anyone know ? I was wondering that too because it was everywhere in the news for a couple of days. Nothing has been said since the Florida Lottery asked to examine the ticket so the News people probably backed off because the circumstances changed. Maybe somebody explained to those people (and they finally understood) why the "th" is placed under the "13". If you remove all the latex from the scratch-off area, most tickets have a 3 letter code like "ONE", "FIV", or "TEN" that shows how much it's worth if it's a winner. I've seen "FTY" and "HUN", but have no idea of what "$500,000 looks like. | | |
United States Member #53025 May 29, 2007 55 Posts Offline | | Posted: June 8, 2007, 12:45 am - IP Logged | |
I imangine it would say 5 mill, like I have seen 1 mill, 2.5 mil 1.5 mill under the number. | | |
United States Member #17858 June 22, 2005 5583 Posts Offline
| | Posted: June 15, 2007, 4:09 pm - IP Logged | |
I'm still scratching my head wondering if they got it or not. I'm just itching to find out. I'm not trying to rub anyone the wrong way, but I am curious. | | |
|