Welcome Guest
Log In | Register )
The time is now 5:57 pm
You last visited September 30, 2014, 5:53 pm
All times shown are
Eastern Time (GMT-5:00)

Pa. Gov. may challenge lottery privatization rejection

Pennsylvania LotteryPennsylvania Lottery: Pa. Gov. may challenge lottery privatization rejection
51
Rating:

Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Corbett is expected to say as soon as Friday whether he will challenge Attorney General Kathleen Kane's rejection of his plan to privatize the state lottery.

If he does, Corbett likely will file his challenge directly with the state Supreme Court, said Duquesne University law professor Bruce Ledewitz. Ledewitz said the case raises questions that Pennsylvania courts have never addressed before.

"There's no smoking gun," Ledewitz said. "The attorney general's opinion in the matter is worthy of respect, but no one could have said this is obviously unconstitutional."

In a decision delivered last week, Kane said Corbett overstepped the executive branch's authority by infringing on the Legislature's power to make basic policy decisions about the operation of the lottery.

The contract's provision to expand the lottery to include electronic games like KENO violates the State Lottery Act and usurps the authority the General Assembly delegated to the Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board, Kane said.

And Kane said the contract's provision for Camelot to sue the state for "indirect expenses" is an unlawful waiver of the state Constitution's sovereign immunity doctrine, which gives the Legislature authority to determine when the state can be held liable for damages.

Franklin & Marshall College pollster G. Terry Madonna said the precise issues Corbett is likely to raise in the challenge are hard to predict. Kane's opinion does not detail how her staff reached the conclusions that warrant invalidating the contract.

While Kane said the State Lottery Act doesn't provide express or implied authority to turn over operation of the lottery to a contractor, it is silent on the limits of the power the Legislature delegated to the executive branch, Madonna said.

"If you don't have specifics like a state law saying what are your responsibilities are, then it's difficult," he said.

Ledewitz said Corbett is likely to ask the Supreme Court to use its power to circumvent the normal flow of cases through the courts and hear the governor's challenge immediately.

The first question the governor's office is likely to pose is how much authority the executive branch has to make fundamental decisions about the implementation of state laws.

Unlike the federal system of government, where the president has broad latitude to implement laws passed by Congress, in the state government, delegation to the executive branch is more limited, Ledewitz said.

Corbett has other options:

  • He could give up on privatizing the lottery, which Ledewitz said is unlikely.
  • He could attempt to have the General Assembly amend the law to give him clear authority.

At least one member of the Legislature indicated a willingness to do just that.

In a House Appropriations Committee hearing Tuesday, Chairman William Adolph, R-Delaware, noted that the administration's goal was to raise more money to benefit the state's growing senior population. The problem could be rectified if the Legislature grants that power to the revenue secretary under the Lottery Act, Adolph said.

But Revenue Secretary Dan Meuser told the panel that the administration's lawyers determined the Camelot agreement is no different than other contracts entered into by the lottery.

Reacting Thursday to a possible legal challenge by the governor, Kane's spokeswoman, Ellen Melody, said: "Should Gov. Corbett choose to challenge the rejection of the Camelot lottery contract, the Office of Attorney General will defend its position."

Kane on Wednesday said the Camelot contract is far more complex than any other services contract.

"It is above and beyond anything the General Assembly has ever intended to be contracted out," she said.

Morning Call, Lottery Post Staff

We'd love to see your comments here!  Register for a FREE membership — it takes just a few moments — and you'll be able to post comments here and on any of our forums. If you're already a member, you can Log In to post a comment.

7 comments. Last comment 2 years ago by luckyshoes.
Page 1 of 1
mightwin's avatar - questns

United States
Member #103789
January 5, 2011
443 Posts
Offline
Posted: February 22, 2013, 10:32 am - IP Logged

Hang on, I have to run to the store to get more popcorn.............

    maximumfun's avatar - Lottery-064.jpg

    United States
    Member #124621
    March 16, 2012
    1484 Posts
    Offline
    Posted: February 22, 2013, 7:07 pm - IP Logged

    Hang on, I have to run to the store to get more popcorn.............

    LOL - seems like privatization is a republican point of view (smaller govt - and the govt being the governing body over the local-esque landscape...) but i sure agree that popcorn would be a great addition... riveting action.

      mightwin's avatar - questns

      United States
      Member #103789
      January 5, 2011
      443 Posts
      Offline
      Posted: February 22, 2013, 7:12 pm - IP Logged

      Seems like government sure is having a difficult time acomplishing anything these days, I wonder what its going to be like for our kids.

        Avatar
        NY
        United States
        Member #23835
        October 16, 2005
        2829 Posts
        Offline
        Posted: February 22, 2013, 11:32 pm - IP Logged

        It depends on how stupid their parents are.

          maximumfun's avatar - Lottery-064.jpg

          United States
          Member #124621
          March 16, 2012
          1484 Posts
          Offline
          Posted: February 23, 2013, 6:25 pm - IP Logged

          It depends on how stupid their parents are.

          oh man... that means we are in serious trouble.

            sully16's avatar - sharan
            Listens to the wind

            United States
            Member #81740
            October 28, 2009
            19638 Posts
            Offline
            Posted: February 24, 2013, 9:10 am - IP Logged

            oh man... that means we are in serious trouble.

            Lots of dumb bells out there

            There's only one US Flag

              luckyshoes's avatar - spook
              Pennsylvania
              United States
              Member #79502
              September 2, 2009
              5067 Posts
              Offline
              Posted: February 25, 2013, 11:38 am - IP Logged

              Corbetts tactic of getting HIS way. Just throw your clout around. But only to HIS advantage.  He sure has power-tripped the office.  Image that- law and order delinquent in the office of governor !