Pennsylvania man arrested after using scissors and glue to make winning lottery tickets

Apr 7, 2021, 9:01 pm (20 comments)

Pennsylvania Lottery

The cut-and-paste con was caught

By Kate Northrop

Police arrested and jailed a Pennsylvania man on Tuesday after he was caught altering scratch-off lottery tickets to look like winners using scissors and a glue stick.

Craig Marshall Stout, 45, of Jeannette tried cashing in his DIY lottery tickets at a 7-Eleven convenience store on Fosterville Road in Hempfield but failed to get away with it — this time.

His cut-and-paste methods had initially worked. Stout brought in three other fake tickets on Friday and Saturday and managed to scam the store of $1,290, employees said. Security camera footage provided to police showed both exchanges in which Stout had gotten away with the con.

This time was different. State police were called to the store at about midnight last night after employees reported the theft attempt. Sitting outside on a motorcycle was Stout, who had tried to swindle the store once more using a ticket that appeared to be a $500 winner.

According to court documents, police seized a pair of scissors, a glue stick, and an unaltered lottery ticket from Stout. He admitted to investigators that he was unemployed, needed some quick cash, and had already spent the money he stole from the store.

Stout was charged with two counts of theft, one count of receiving stolen property, one count of forgery, and another count of possession of an instrument of crime with intent. His bail was set at $25,000, with a preliminary hearing set for April 16. He is currently being held at Westmoreland County Prison.

Previous online records also show that Stout was sentenced to one year on probation in July and had his driver's license suspended for six months following numerous charges of driving offenses, including driving without a license and causing damage to another vehicle or property.

Sadly, it's not the first time that someone would attempt to steal a lottery prize by gluing together a fake winning ticket. A year ago two Mississippi men tried the same technique — and were also caught.

Lottery Post Staff

Comments

grwurston's avatargrwurston
HaveABall's avatarHaveABall

I don't understand how the Lottery Headquarter's computer didn't catch this two out of the three times.  Now this store owner isn't going to get their hundreds of dollars back.

Confused

Think's avatarThink

You can just see this one coming.  Next he will sue the store for accepting and cashing invalid tickets...hmmm...lets see legal fees...pain...suffering...loss of reputation....I bet the way he sees it that should be good for a couple million...why oh why did they not tell him those tickets were not valid..he didn't force them to cash the tickets...wouldn't surprise me if he tried it!

chris632's avatarchris632

Quote: Originally posted by HaveABall on Apr 7, 2021

I don't understand how the Lottery Headquarter's computer didn't catch this two out of the three times.  Now this store owner isn't going to get their hundreds of dollars back.

Confused

I don't either. The first thing they do is scan the ticket so how could they cash it?

Chris

kao1632

Quote: Originally posted by HaveABall on Apr 7, 2021

I don't understand how the Lottery Headquarter's computer didn't catch this two out of the three times.  Now this store owner isn't going to get their hundreds of dollars back.

Confused

The only way I can see it working is if the store operator didn't scan the ticket.

So, why might they not scan the ticket...

Wasn't there a "scam" where sellers would give cash to a winner and claim the prize themselves? (something about avoiding letting the government know you had a windfall for people who had outstanding debts etc...

dannyct

What an Einstein!

Bleudog101

IDK about this.   Something in my mind just not adding up.   The tickets must not have been scanned since the barcode would indicate not a winning ticket.

Well he has three hots and a cot now @ taxpayer's expense of course.

ThatScaryChick's avatarThatScaryChick

I don't know why but the title of the article made me laugh. ROFL

PHIL85

This article is incomplete. As others mentioned retailers scan a ticket which tells them whether it is a winner or not and what it is worth. The ticket has to be verified before payment can be made. So the big question is why did the store pay out anything in the first place when the tickets in question were not actually winners?

LottoNoobie

It seems like he probably glued on matching numbers to create the winning ticket. May be he was charming enough to get the clerk to just cash the ticket in without actually scanning it. Or he intentionally messed up the bar code so it couldn't be scanned and said "Look, a winning number is 25 and I matched it for $500." That's just my theory.

Bleudog101

Quote: Originally posted by LottoNoobie on Apr 9, 2021

It seems like he probably glued on matching numbers to create the winning ticket. May be he was charming enough to get the clerk to just cash the ticket in without actually scanning it. Or he intentionally messed up the bar code so it couldn't be scanned and said "Look, a winning number is 25 and I matched it for $500." That's just my theory.

We may never know...but somehow thinking the clerk was in on this...?

wander73's avatarwander73

Too funny.  It sounds similiar to the guys back in the 80s putting the water balls in the machine.   Why would anyone do that?

wander73's avatarwander73

Quote: Originally posted by HaveABall on Apr 7, 2021

I don't understand how the Lottery Headquarter's computer didn't catch this two out of the three times.  Now this store owner isn't going to get their hundreds of dollars back.

Confused

Doesn't every lottery outlet in the US have cameras?   Same as casinos,   casinos things happen people try to have their ways.

wander73's avatarwander73

Quote: Originally posted by Think on Apr 8, 2021

You can just see this one coming.  Next he will sue the store for accepting and cashing invalid tickets...hmmm...lets see legal fees...pain...suffering...loss of reputation....I bet the way he sees it that should be good for a couple million...why oh why did they not tell him those tickets were not valid..he didn't force them to cash the tickets...wouldn't surprise me if he tried it!

The judge would throw it out.   Cameras in the store too.  wouldn't make it that far.   think about it.  it's not worth it and the tax payers as well.

Subscribe to this news story