New Florida lottery law increases prizes

May 29, 2005, 10:01 am (30 comments)

Florida Lottery Florida lottery players soon will rake in more dough when they win games such as Lotto, Mega Money and Fantasy 5, thanks to a bill signed into law Thursday by Gov. Jeb Bush.

Bush, an outspoken critic of gambling, and state lottery officials are betting that the higher payouts will boost ticket sales for the games, similar to a measure passed three years ago that doubled the sales of scratch-off games.

Higher sales should mean more money for education, which is the stated purpose of the new law. Although increasing the payouts will decrease the percentage of ticket sales going to education, officials say the overall growth in income will boost education dollars.

Bush said he was signing the bill because the lottery pays for Bright Futures scholarships — a program whose growth will exceed its finances in coming years if nothing is done to increase lottery proceeds.

But even the best-case scenario shows that most of the extra money will go back to the lucky winners, not to education.

According to state estimates, boosting payouts from the current 50 percent of gross revenues to 60 percent would increase ticket sales by nearly $1 billion, but would mean only $103.8 million in extra money for education. Winners would net an extra $774.3 million and the state would get an extra $108.6 million for administration of the program.

Under current law, a $1 billion increase in sales would mean $390 million extra for education, but there's no reason to believe sales would increase that much without the impetus of larger payouts.

Florida law currently mandates that at least 39 percent of the revenue goes to the Education Enhancement Trust Fund, which is to be used for educational items such as school construction and Bright Futures scholarships.

Lottery officials have not determined how the increase in payouts will be handled for what they call their online games — Florida Lotto, Mega Money, Fantasy 5, Play 4 and Cash 3.

They must determine, for example, whether to use all of the extra money in a game such as Lotto for a Pick-6 payout, or whether to spread it among the 3-, 4- and 5-match winners.

Or they could use the extra money in special one-time promotions with higher jackpots.

Officials say they plan to increase the online payouts from 50 to 53 percent this year, then to 55 percent next year and to as much as 60 percent soon afterward.

A legislative revenue estimating conference predicted that increasing payouts for online games to 54 percent this year could hike sales by nearly $400 million, putting an extra $65 million into the education trust fund.

Last year, the Florida lottery generated more than $3 billion in sales of instant, or scratch-off, tickets and online tickets combined. Of that, about $1 billion — or about 34 percent — went to education, and $1.7 billion was given away in prizes.

Since 2002, when lottery officials began to increase the payouts on instant tickets, sales have more than doubled — from $662 million in 2001-02 to $1.36 billion in 2003-04, making instant ticket sales nearly half of all lottery sales.

Online sales grew by only 14 percent during the same period.

But the instant ticket sales contribute only 35 percent of the total lottery money transferred into the education trust fund.

The new law gives lottery officials unregulated authority to vary the percentages of gross revenues that go back to players as prize money, which in turn lowers the percentages of revenues going to education. But the law requires that the "percentages must be established by the Lottery in a manner designed to maximize deposits in the Educational Enhancement Trust Fund."

The legislative revenue estimating conference estimated that the maximum benefit to the fund would be a 60 percent payout, which would reduce the percentage going to education to 29 percent. Eleven percent is always reserved for administration of the program, including payouts to stores that sell lottery tickets.

Research shows that increasing prize payouts for instant tickets still nets a "good transfer" for education, Bureau of Economic and Demographic Research analyst Pam Johnson said.

But, she cautioned, no such evidence exists for the online games.

"Basically, we don't expect to see nearly the same kind of response," she said.

And there is no guarantee in the new law that the current amount of money deposited into the education trust fund will continue if ticket sales fail to meet expectations.

The bill signed by Bush also requires that 80 percent of unclaimed prizes to go directly into the education trust fund and 20 percent to go back to the Florida Lottery.

Previously, lottery officials could increase the payouts of online games by dumping unclaimed prize money, about $30 million a year, into the prize pools.

But a legislative analysis said that the "direct transfer of unclaimed prize money would generate no new money for education."

"Taking the unclaimed prize money would mean the Lottery would transfer that much less money from sales," the analysis said. "This loss would be offset by the deposit of the unclaimed prize money into the EETF, resulting in no net gain for education."

Palm Beach Post

Tags for this story

Other popular tags

Comments

CASH Only

Two thoughts:

1) Jeb Bush won't bring Powerball or MM to his state, but he OKs the Florida Lottery to pay out a higher percentage to winners;

2) Why can't NY improve the paltry 38%-40% return in Lotto?

Todd's avatarTodd

Nice job Jeb! 

CASH Only

todd:

FL still needs to go multi-state.

Todd's avatarTodd

One of the really interesting things about Jeb Bush signing this bill is that it shows he values the dollars to education more than his dislike of gambling.  To me, it is a promising indication that he may be open to Powerball in Florida.

CASH Only

todd:

I hope you're right.

CASH Only

The lower tier prizes in FL Lotto are already generous (compared to NY Lotto), so FL should add the excess money to its Lotto jackpot (start at $4 million?)

www.flalottery.com

www.nylottery.org

MADDOG10's avatarMADDOG10

 now thats the kind of "open minded" thinking we need in all lotteries.  cogratulations to Mr. Jeb Bush for showing he the intestonal fortitude to keep an open mind, while still being an open critic of gambling..... 

Tnplayer805's avatarTnplayer805

I think FL will join powerball, however, it won't be for a few years. 

LOTTOMIKE's avatarLOTTOMIKE

PLEASE tell me they aren't going to raise the price of a regular online ticket to make this happen....

MPJO

Is Mega Millions going to stay put at 12 states?

I think Florida would be a good fit for MM.

Pick-4_Master

I doubt very seriously an increase in ticket price will occur if it does that might cause some problems with players, us joining Mega-Millions I guess would be okay but the FL Lottery Commision might not want it too compete against the popular Mega-Money game which is somewhat similiar only we have 4 picks and less numbers for the Bonus Ball.

Todd's avatarTodd



Is Mega Millions going to stay put at 12 states?

I think Florida would be a good fit for MM.



That's what they have said in the past.  They said the next big state (CA) would be the last.

Tnplayer805's avatarTnplayer805

I think powerball would be best for FL.  (Anyone else sense another matrix change if FL joins?).  FL's lotto is ok,however, it seems like everyother draw someone wins it.  Not really a jackpot ruled lottery if you ask me.  Also, powerball and the FL lotto would be played on the same night.  That could be bad for FL lotto if they do add powerball.  If I was FL's director this is what I would do:

1. Join Powerball. 2. Move Mega Money drawings to Monday and Thursday Nights.  3. Move the FL lotto to Tuesday and Friday Night. 4. Take out the $2 million MAX jackpot for Mega Money.  5. Add a cash option to Mega Money.  6. Add midday drawings to Fan 5, cash 3, and Pick 4.  The Florida Lottery is a great lottery and when I move to Mobile, AL in August I'll have to drive a little and try it out.

Pick-4_Master

Mega-Millions would be a better choice than PowerBall but Mr.Jeb Bush may never make a decision too join either of them personally I've always liked Mega-Millions over PowerBall.I can't wait too see how much the Prize payouts will increase I already e-mailed them too see what they say.

Tnplayer805's avatarTnplayer805

I like Powerball over Mega Millions (I guess it's because it's played in TN and since I live close to the border we've either play MM or The Big Game for a long time).  I do play GA's Mega Millions when the jackpots get high.  (Kinda like Tuesday's). 

Pick-4_Master

Didn't PowerBall increase the number field recently? I know it's a 5/53 (our Lottery is a 6/53) maybe it was the PowerBall they increased.I know Mega-Millions increased the number Matrix for the Mega Ball those 2 games are very hard to analyse so if we did join any of them I probably wouldn't play.It's best too just buy quick-picks unless you can afford to Wheel a lot of numbers.

Tnplayer805's avatarTnplayer805

Powerball is going to change their Matrix but I forgot when.  (I think August 29 or something like that).  Anyway, I only play powerball or MM when jackpots are high.  As for wheels or QP or whatever I don't wheel.  I always pick my numbers randomly.  I don't play QP because everytime I do I always end up with some very bad numbers like 1-2-3-9-10 PB 1.  LOL atleast I wouldn't have to worry about anyone else winning the JP.

JimmySand9



I think powerball would be best for FL.  (Anyone else sense another matrix change if FL joins?).  FL's lotto is ok,however, it seems like everyother draw someone wins it.  Not really a jackpot ruled lottery if you ask me.  Also, powerball and the FL lotto would be played on the same night.  That could be bad for FL lotto if they do add powerball.  If I was FL's director this is what I would do:

1. Join Powerball. 2. Move Mega Money drawings to Monday and Thursday Nights.  3. Move the FL lotto to Tuesday and Friday Night. 4. Take out the $2 million MAX jackpot for Mega Money.  5. Add a cash option to Mega Money.  6. Add midday drawings to Fan 5, cash 3, and Pick 4.  The Florida Lottery is a great lottery and when I move to Mobile, AL in August I'll have to drive a little and try it out.



Mega Money has a cash option.

JimmySand9

I'm just afraid that they'll go to RNG's to "save money" to make up for the games' higher payouts. It would be a shame to see America's premier state lottery go the route of dishonesty.

Pick-4_Master

I've contacted the FL Lottery Commision on that issue before, they say there are no plans on eliminating there Draw Machines because it would create a problem with PLAYER confidence in the games if a Random Number Generator were used.

Pick-4_Master

If this state wants too keep the Games popular and profitable changing over to RNG's like other states would be a serious mistake so I doubt that it would happen also there would be Tremendous opposition from the Public and Political Officials.

JimmySand9



I've contacted the FL Lottery Commision on that issue before, they say there are no plans on eliminating there Draw Machines because it would create a problem with PLAYER confidence in the games if a Random Number Generator were used.



A lottery that actually cares about it's player confidence! If they really do think that, all they need are some Criterions and some Powerball and they would hit the pinnacle of lottery quality (once they increase the payouts of course).

CASH Only

Re Mega Money: it began as an all-cash game.

MPJO

 

 Mega Millions would be the better fit since it is on Tuesday and Friday.

 It's the right thing to do!!!

wizeguy's avatarwizeguy



Powerball is going to change their Matrix but I forgot when.  (I think August 29 or something like that).  Anyway, I only play powerball or MM when jackpots are high.  As for wheels or QP or whatever I don't wheel.  I always pick my numbers randomly.  I don't play QP because everytime I do I always end up with some very bad numbers like 1-2-3-9-10 PB 1.  LOL atleast I wouldn't have to worry about anyone else winning the JP.



LOL, I always get the high numbers on QP (which I use often)

dvdiva's avatardvdiva

They should join Megamillions then move the drawings for Megamoney to the same night as Megamillions and make sure that the playslips look very similar. Then we can hear the horror stories of morons living in palm beach whining that they really meant to play megamillions not megamoney.

Pick-4_Master

Mega-Money is drawn every Tue & Fri I thought Mega-Millions was drawn on the same 2 days?

CASH Only

Mega Millions Tue & Fri.

JimmySand9

Well, Florida won't be able to join Mega Millions, and even if they could they'd probably still join PB to get Georgia players over the border. Of course, joining Powerball would necessitate an overhaul of draw nights. Lotto would need to move to Tuesdays and Fridays, and Mega Money would need to move to Mondays and Thursdays. At least that's what they'd need to do to keep people playing on those games. And anyway, with these required higher payouts, what will Florida do about Powerball, which will continue paying 50%. Maybe put the extra 10% in a bonus fund for Powerball promotions, like a occasional PowerPlay doubler where 2x means 4x, 5x means 10x, that kind of thing. Oh, I'm getting the shakes just thinking about the idea of PowerPlaying back home in Tampa (where speaking of PowerPlays, is home to the World Champion Tampa Bay Lightning, GO BOLTS!).

Tnplayer805's avatarTnplayer805

Well, Florida won't be able to join Mega Millions, and even if they could they'd probably still join PB to get Georgia players over the border. Of course, joining Powerball would necessitate an overhaul of draw nights. Lotto would need to move to Tuesdays and Fridays, and Mega Money would need to move to Mondays and Thursdays. At least that's what they'd need to do to keep people playing on those games. And anyway, with these required higher payouts, what will Florida do about Powerball, which will continue paying 50%. Maybe put the extra 10% in a bonus fund for Powerball promotions, like a occasional PowerPlay doubler where 2x means 4x, 5x means 10x, that kind of thing. Oh, I'm getting the shakes just thinking about the idea of PowerPlaying back home in Tampa (where speaking of PowerPlays, is home to the World Champion Tampa Bay Lightning, GO BOLTS!).

That solution would be great.  A major lotto game almost on every night. 

End of comments
Subscribe to this news story
Guest