Welcome Guest
Log In | Register )
You last visited January 9, 2009, 8:26 pm

POLL 1 of 3: Computerized drawings vs. ball drawings

Topic locked. Last post more than one year ago by scorpio. 46 replies.

Page 3 of 5 BackForwardGo to Page
Print E-mail Link

Do you prefer computerized drawings or mechanical ball machine drawings?

Computerized drawings [ 17 ]  [7.26%]
Mechanical ball machine drawings [ 217 ]  [92.74%]
Total Valid Votes [ 234 ]  
Discarded Votes [ 2 ]  
Gold Member
Advanced
Greenwich, CT
United States
Member #4879
May 24, 2004
1822 Posts
Offline
Posted: August 29, 2007, 5:05 pm - IP Logged Bottom

  I think I've made my position very clear on this subject. Aside from the very valid argument that they're more easily and undetectably compromised, using computers to draw lottery numbers removes an essential element from all of the games. We enjoy the excitement of watching the balls blow around inside the hoppers, watching our numbers roll out one by one and, most of all, anticipating that final number while our hearts pound so hard we think we'll pass out or die.

  Now, that's exciting; that's a real lottery drawing.

   I've watched tens of thousands of true lottery drawings over the years, and I don't remember thinking, even once, "Gee, I wish these drawings were more technologically advanced." Funny thing is, I've never seen even ONE drawing made by a computer. I've seen animated images of computer drawings that were made to look like they were drawn using balls, but I've never seen the actual drawing in real time.

  I wish someone would apply this wonderful technology to a game that would cause the general public to see what we've seen. I wish some sports team owner would wake up and realize that he could save hundreds of millions of dollars per year just by creating and organizing virtual football or basketball teams. No more injuries; no more scandals and no more multi-million dollar player contracts. My God; why NOT do it? NASCAR sponsors and owners could also save scads of money by turning live races into video games, as they've done with these virtual lottery drawings. 

  Just because new technology is available for a given application does not necessarily indicate that it can or should be adopted. We have the technology to enable our government to know, at any given moment, what ANYONE in the country is doing, even while they're inside their own homes. Does this mean we should allow them to do it? We have the technology and means to decimate every other country in the world. Why isn't this technology being utilized? These are extreme examples, to be sure, but here's one more: We have the technology to grow staple crops in pure desert sand. I don't have to ask why this technology isn't being employed, because I already know the answer. It costs 27% more to grow corn or soybeans in hot sand than it does to grow it in soil in a less-hostile climate, thus negating any potential profit (wheat costs 18% more to grow in the desert but, for some reason, sand-grown wheat yields 6% more grain per acre).

  So far, with the lone exception of the very first state to convert to using an RNG (I think it was Connecticut, but I wouldn't swear to it), every other state lottery that has embraced these machines has made the same comment: "Other states are already using this technology, and it's important that we keep up with industry trends."

  I'm waiting for the day when a lottery public relations spokesman says, "Well, other state lottery directors were jumping off bridges, so ..."

Definitely not Connecticut.  Still all balls.

tntea's avatar - Lottery 059
Standard Member
Top 25 Poster
Guru

United States
Member #5437
June 30, 2004
21790 Posts
Offline
Posted: August 30, 2007, 7:30 am - IP Logged Bottom Top

I am with you on this.  I quit them too.  Best chance to even come close in TN now with Pick 3 is to do a qp and hope it is a number that was played the least.

YES WE CAN

csfb's avatar - Lottery 001
Standard Member
Regular

United States
Member #15582
May 13, 2005
307 Posts
Offline
Posted: August 30, 2007, 8:16 am - IP Logged Bottom Top

I chose balls.  I wondered though about the make of the balls.  For example, balls of metal vs. balls of rubber.   Would there be a predictable difference in the outcome?

         Sun Smiley             


United States
Member #16902
June 2, 2005
3493 Posts
Offline
Posted: August 30, 2007, 2:09 pm - IP Logged Bottom Top

I hate computer drawings. I like ball drawings that are fair as my vote.

Standard Member
Senior
Coastal Georgia
United States
Member #2703
October 30, 2003
1868 Posts
Offline
Posted: August 30, 2007, 5:46 pm - IP Logged Bottom Top

101 to 7 at this juncture in favor of balls...

 

                               

              

 

 

Rocket 455's avatar - rocket
Platinum Member
Advanced
Bellevue Kentucky
United States
Member #53817
July 4, 2007
1261 Posts
Offline
Posted: August 30, 2007, 10:38 pm - IP Logged Bottom Top

 Random will never be programmed, I don't care what any computer scientist says. Just like voting machines, it's too easy to stack the deck with hidden code. And if you did finally figure out the rhythm the programmer would just change it. Less hits for the people who play this game. The answer is simple.

 Balls Sun Smiley

 "Blackbird fly, Blackbird fly

  Into the light of the dark black night." The Beatles


United States
Member #16902
June 2, 2005
3493 Posts
Offline
Posted: August 31, 2007, 2:05 pm - IP Logged Bottom Top

I hate computer drawings. I like ball drawings that are fair as my vote.

I don't like computer drawings. The odds of winning a jackpot is better fair if it's ball drawn.

Platinum Member
Regular
EAST COAST, USA
United States
Member #49886
January 31, 2007
354 Posts
Offline
Posted: September 3, 2007, 9:09 am - IP Logged Bottom Top

I know there have been many polls like this before, but let's do a fresh poll, to find out what the current feelings of lottery players are.  I'd appreciate as much participation as possible, no matter what your viewpoint is.

Please indicate your preference as to what type of lottery drawings your prefer —

  • Computerized drawings, which use a computer system to generate random numbers.  Some computerized states show the results in an animated cartoon sequence, and other computerized states have dropped television productions.
  • Mechanical ball drawings, which use a bin or tub to mix numbered ping pong balls or hard rubber balls, and from which the winning numbers are drawn.  Most ball drawings are broadcast on television live or taped and shown later.

Enter one choice or the other, even if you are swayed ever so slightly one way or the other.

You may enter a comment as well, but it is optional.

Also, please participate in the other two polls posted.

POLL 1 of 3: Computerized drawings vs. ball drawings
You are currently viewing this poll

POLL 2 of 3: Switching to computerized drawings
http://www.lotterypost.com/thread/161744

POLL 3 of 3: Switching to mechanical ball drawings
http://www.lotterypost.com/thread/161743

What type of drawing does NC and SC have? Whatever it is it works for me.

Platinum Member
Regular
EAST COAST, USA
United States
Member #49886
January 31, 2007
354 Posts
Offline
Posted: September 3, 2007, 10:19 pm - IP Logged Bottom Top

Okay, don't flog me here, but I chose Computerized drawings because that would open up possibilities that maybe it would be possible to create a system that could get hits more often than trying to guess the machine ball outcome.

Seems I've heard that it's pretty tough to actually write a true RNG program and maybe players could spot a rythmn or glitch and take advantage of it.

The outcome of a Mechanical ball machine is pretty tough to unravel in my opinion. Maybe I'd have better luck with RNG's.

I'm in that small percentage also Steve. I agree with your philosophy.  But only because I know it to be true.

Platinum Member
New Member
New Member

United States
Member #50669
March 1, 2007
4 Posts
Offline
Posted: September 6, 2007, 7:15 pm - IP Logged Bottom Top

What type of drawing does NC and SC have? Whatever it is it works for me.

Look at the State Lottery Report Card in the results menu.  Every game and state is listed.

 
Page 3 of 5 BackForwardGo to Page
Top