First winner disqualified in 145-year history of Derby
Maximum Security led all the way in the Kentucky Derby on Saturday, only to become the first winner disqualified for interference in the race's 145-year history. After a long wait, 65-1 shot Country House was declared the winner.
The announcement seemed to come from the heavens, and then all hell broke loose.
"Hold all tickets."
Country House was declared the winner of Saturday's Kentucky Derby at Churchill Downs after the second disqualification in the race's 145-year history. Maximum Security crossed the finish line first in 2:03.93 but was moved to 17th place after a lengthy review.
Many in the rain-soaked crowd of 150,729 booed the result. Connections of Maximum Security celebrated in the winner's circle but were quickly escorted out, replaced by Country House's connections.
As the race stewards reviewed the video, Country House trainer Bill Mott stood in the middle of the sloppy Churchill track, surrounded by reporters.
"They don't take many horses down in the Kentucky Derby," Mott said before the disqualification was announced. "If it was a maiden $10,000 on a Thursday, it would be a no-brainer. They don't want the controversy, I'm sure, but you're supposed to keep a straight line."
Maximum Security trainer Jason Servis — thinking he had just joined his brother, John (Smarty Jones in 2004), as the trainer of a Kentucky Derby winner — had just finished an interview with NBC when the "Hold all tickets" call came down.
Servis said he had received "a million" texts of congratulations.
"Now they're all texting me back — 'Sorry. Sorry,'" Servis said.
At 65-1 odds, Country House posted the second-biggest upset in Derby history, behind only Donerail's victory at 91-1 in 1913. Country House paid $132.40 and finished three-quarters of a length ahead of Code of Honor. Tacitus was third.
Bob Baffert came up short in his attempt to become the second trainer to win six Kentucky Derbys. His trio finished fourth (Improbable), fifth (Game Winner) and 15th (Roadster), leaving Ben Jones as the only six-time winner.
Maximum Security, the previously undefeated winner of the Florida Derby, set the early pace with quick fractions of 22.31 seconds for the quarter-mile and 46.62 seconds for the half-mile. Long Range Toddy, Bodexpress and War of Will chased closely behind.
Meanwhile, Country House — with the reputation of being a late closer — was much closer than Mott expected on the backstretch.
"I thought he'd be further back," Mott said. "He was on his game today. Country House was close to the pace. ... No matter how hard you look at it, you just never know when they leave the gate who's going to show that early speed."
Maximum Security, ridden by Luis Saez, still led with 5/16ths of a mile to go when he veered into War of Will, which forced Long Range Toddy jockey Jon Court to check his horse. Long Range Toddy finished 16th, which led to Maximum Security being placed 17th in the 19-horse field. Maximum Security win wagers placed with Twin Spires will be refunded.
Mott said Country House was only mildly affected by Maximum Security's foul. Chief steward Barbara Borden said Country House jockey Flavien Prat and Court filed objections against Maximum Security, claiming interference.
"We determined that (Maximum Security) drifted out and impacted the progress of (War of Will), in turn interfering with (Long Range Toddy) and (Bodexpress)," said Borden, who issued a statement but did not take questions from reporters. "Those horses were all affected, we thought, by the interference. Therefore, we unanimously determined to disqualify (Maximum Security) and place him behind (Long Range Toddy), (Long Range Toddy) being the lowest-placed horse that he bothered, which is our typical procedure."
Mott said Maximum Security "switched to his wrong lead and bore out."
"And when he did, he forced some horses to come together," Mott said. "There were a couple of jocks that had to stand straight up at a very critical time of the race. There were still two horses that were very much in the race to get a big piece of it, and they took all chance away from them."
Later on, Mott said, "With that said, I'm damn glad they put our number up."
Servis said he'd need to watch a replay of the race before deciding whether the stewards' decision was correct.
"The only thing I saw was him duck out a little," Servis said. "With the crowd and stuff, it's hard to say if he saw something or got scared. I didn't get to see it that well."
Take our poll: Who deserves the title of 145th winner of the Kentucky Derby?
Read more: How the 2019 Kentucky Derby winner Country House got its name
A son of Lookin At Lucky out of the War Chant mare Quake Lake, Country House improved to 2-2-1 in seven career starts for co-owners Maury Shields, Guinness McFadden and LNJ Foxwoods.
The only other Derby winner to be disqualified was Dancer's Image in 1968, who was found to have used prohibited medication. Forward Pass was the declared the winner.
For Country House, it's on to the Preakness on May 18 in Baltimore.
"As far as the win goes, it's actually bittersweet," said Mott, the Hall of Fame trainer who picked up his first Derby victory. "I'd be lying if I said it was any different. You always want to win with a clean trip and have everybody recognize the horse as the very good horse and great athlete that he is. Due to the disqualification, probably some of that is diminished."
(Click to display full-size in gallery)
(Click to display full-size in gallery)
(Click to display full-size in gallery)
Tough Call considering the Condition of the Track!
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/04/sports/kentucky-derby-stewards-video-review.html
Ridiculous!
your riding a horse not driving a car plus look at the track sloppy let them have a run off and see who will win
Race stewards are highly educated for all the rules and regulations on horse racing. Lay people like myself don't know the ins and outs of all this, but the many, many different videos they've showed here in Kentucky you may not like their decision, but I do see their point. Do I honestly think it is fair, heck no. How would a jockey know a horse was right behind him? The jockey admitted his horse was spooked with all the noise after the final turn.
View the Video: It's obvious the Wrong Horse & Rider was Disqualified!
Off topic, but how on earth has this news story anything to do with lottery? Will Lottery Post start posting news about cricket and soccer in the future?
Don't know if you've seen all the videos, all angles except for directly overhead and it was a rules violation, unfortunately.
You don't think any lottery players be the Derby?
I found it refreshing to read personally and welcomed a change of scenery.
Lotto and horse race betting have an intertwined history. The earliest numbers games (Pick 3) used the last three digits of the local racetrack handle as the official draw. Chances are if you're interested in one form of gambling such as the lottery, you're interested in other forms. I see nothing out of place here.
The strategy when a horse is outrun during the early stages of the race, and then gets into gear too late to overtake the leader is to whine about the leader interfering and get the leader disqualified.
I watched it and did notice they were close at some point in the race but with the soupy mud I am surprised there was no collision but did not think any wrongdoing. I do not agree with the disqualification. That third picture in the story was an awesome shot.
First time in 145 year history sounds like sour grapes. Sad ending to what was a great race imo.
It would be a better "no call" especially for a sport that's on the decline. Taking down the winner is nothing new to horse racing, but doing it on National TV to the favorite is unprecedented.
When I saw the payoffs, the first thing I thought was how PB and MM have created huge jackpots to entice new players and the comparison to past and this year's Derby payoffs. My sister-in-law always bets "across the board" on four for five long shots and won almost $250. But it's really the exotic bet payoffs that reminded me of jackpot lottery games. In the last three years 10 cent superfecta bets paid $7500, $1980 and this year $5140. A 50 cent bet this year returns $1500 on the exacta and $5727 for the trifecta. And for a the 2018 Derby, a player in Texas won $1.2 million by betting $18 Louisville Downs pick-5.
"how on earth has this news story anything to do with lottery?"
For many reasons including the payoffs, enticing new players, and creating the results. Besides in the past we had lots of KY Derby, Triple Crown, and Breeders Cup discussions so while not directly lottery related, lots of people here want to vent about the stewards decision and why not?
I never cared for horse racing, but I did watch videos, and it is clear that Maximum Security swung wide into the path of the other horses, and in fact his back legs clipped War of Will's front legs twice. It's really amazing there wasn't a massive pileup. If that horse goes down at the front, bad news.
Maximum Security's jockey did say he thought his horse got spooked momentarily, but got him back under control.
Maximum Security definitely drifted wide on the turn, but Derby stewards have historically ignored infractions and didn't file an inquiry until after three jockeys filed their objections.
Read where the owner is going to appeal to the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission
The better Horse (Maximum Security) & Jockey (Flavien Prat) came in First!
KY Horse Racing Commission denied their appeal. To the Federal level we go.
I don't believe there is a commission at the Federal level that could change the official results. And it's not like if it was changed they could get the money back from the Country House betters and give it to the Maximum Security betters.
IDK either, but that's what the owners said there next option is. Time to move on.
810 KAR 1:016. Running of the race.
Section 12. Fouls. A leading horse if clear is entitled to any part of the track. If a leading horse or any other horse in a race swerves or is ridden to either side so as to interfere with, intimidate, or impede any other horse or jockey, or to cause the same result, this action shall be deemed a foul. If a jockey strikes another horse or jockey, it is a foul. If in the opinion of the stewards a foul alters the finish of a race, an offending horse may be disqualified by the stewards.
The owner's of Maximum Security just filed a federal lawsuit in Frankfort, KY in regards to the results of the 145th Kentucky Derby!