Douglas
Would "It may be too good to be true" qualify as an oxymoron?
"It may be too good to be true" Does not seem like a proper logical thought.
"it may be true to be too good" That might be more coherent, but it is also a weird way of saying some-thing.

Just playing around with word order. Sometimes I see a phrase, saying or sentence and run through the possible word order permutations. Kind of a fun game to play. Like the blog title, 'think carefully' or 'carefully think'. Seems strangely the same, but different. Seems strangely different, but the same. It's fun, try it.

Another would be... it may be too true to be good.

As English is not my native language and to make matters worse, I am getting old, when I write something, to me is more like, "Which way is the right way in which and or how to phrase what I am trying to say?"
Well, Douglas, Have fun.