Welcome Guest
Log In | Register )
You last visited December 8, 2016, 4:45 am
All times shown are
Eastern Time (GMT-5:00)

A state lottery could help Alabama get its financial house in order

AlabamaAlabama: A state lottery could help Alabama get its financial house in order
51
Rating:

Fifty years ago, lotteries were illegal in every state, but they have proven so lucrative and politically irresistible that 44 states have since started selling tickets to the lottery. In 2013, state-run lotteries brought in $62 billion, which amounts to $257 in sales to every adult in the nation.

Six stubborn holdouts remain. Alaska and Hawaii are isolated enough that they do not feel pressured by sales from their neighbors. Nevada and Mississippi have gambling lobbies that don't want a state lottery encroaching on their turf. Mississippi, Utah and Alabama have strong religious constituencies that do not want their flocks led astray.

Until last year, Wyoming, too, did not have a lottery. But lawmakers were concerned about all the money their residents were spending in next-door Idaho to buy lottery tickets. "This is a way to keep Wyoming money in Wyoming," Gov. Matt Mead (R ) said at the time. Lottery proponents also hope to attract customers from nearby Utah, which continues to abstain.

Alabama might be the next to break down and start a lottery. For years, it has used loans, savings and one-time windfalls to balance its budget. Now it faces an intractable $200-300 million shortfall — a $700 million shortfall if all the borrowed money is thrown into the calculation.

"We knew this day was going to come. We knew this crisis was going to take place, and it's here," Gov. Robert Bentley (R ) said in a speech Monday morning.

Bentley has drawn criticism from his own party over his proposal for a $541 million tax increase, largely paid for by increases in the cigarette tax and the auto sales tax. So far, the Republican-controlled legislature has resisted his demands for new revenue. They are asking state agencies to submit plans for budget cuts in the vicinity of 15 to 30 percent.

Democrats in the state have come up with a third solution. A lottery, argues Rep. Craig Ford (D), could put a huge dent in the state's budget problems — bringing in perhaps $280 million a year. Alabama Democrats have been proposing lottery legislation for years, but this time is different. The situation in Alabama is dire enough that a top Republican has added his name to the bill as well.

"We're just looking at anything to raise funds," Rep. Steve Clouse (R) told local papers. Clouse chairs the state's General Fund Committee, which handles all spending except for education, which is paid for out of a separate budget. Earlier this month, Clouse endorsed a lottery bill that would earmark the money for the state's strained Medicaid program (which has not taken federal Medicaid expansion money).

These debates are déja vu for many Alabamians, who remember a similar battle 15 years ago when the state nearly got the lottery.

The lottery is a divisive issue, but it cuts through constituencies in funny ways. In the South, the chief opponents are religious groups, who say that gambling is immoral — and moreover, it preys on the poor. Proponents tend to be Democrats, who focus on all the good that the lottery money can do — paying for schools or scholarships, for instance. [Editor: This commonly-held belief about political stances is actually a myth, as many high-profile liberal personalities have been quite vocal in their opposition to state lotteries.]

Versions of these arguments have echoed for centuries. In fact, some of the oldest lotteries in America also raised money for education. In the 1700s, the Massachusetts legislature allowed Harvard to run lotteries to fund dorm construction. Yale, Columbia and Princeton did the same. Later on, lotteries would also help raise money for troops during the Revolutionary War, and after independence, they paid for roads, canals and other public infrastructure.

A series of lottery scandals, combined with the growing social reform movement, prompted most states to outlaw gambling in the mid-1800s. (Much of it continued in illegal form.) The last legal lottery, licensed by the state of Louisiana, shut down in the 1890s in a stink of corruption. By then, the federal government had also banned lottery tickets from being shipped across state lines or mailed anywhere.

States wouldn't return to the idea of lotteries as revenue sources until the second half of the 20th century. In 1964, New Hampshire began selling $3 raffle tickets to raise money for public education. In just the first year, it sold $59 million in tickets. Other states quickly copied New Hampshire, in most cases rolling back their own constitutional prohibitions on such games. New York got the lottery in 1967, followed by New Jersey in 1970.

The rest of the states fell in line within a few decades, starting in the Northeast and catching on across the country. New Hampshire and New York had shown that the modern state-run lottery was more or less clean and scandal-free. In addition, widespread anti-tax sentiment in the 1970s and 1980s had put states in a bind. The lottery — and other gambling measures — became an enticing option for legislatures that needed revenue but wanted to avoid the ugliness of a tax increase.

These days, states have become so dependent on lottery money that many have turned turned to gimmicks in an effort to shore up their sales. California has launched a series of ads appealing to the state's hippie roots. "Believe in something bigger," is the state lottery's motto. In New Hampshire, you can now buy bacon-scented scratch-off cards.

"It's one of the great transformations in American life," said Michael Nelson, a political science professor at Rhodes College in Tennessee. "We've gone from a country in which one state had casinos and no states had lotteries, to a country in which lots of states have casinos and virtually every state has a lottery."

Some of the last holdouts were states in the Bible Belt, where religious objections to gambling still had force, as Nelson and his colleague John Lyman Mason describe in their book, "How the South Joined the Gambling Nation."

So Oklahoma, Tennessee and the Carolinas didn't get the lottery until the early 2000s; Arkansas didn't join the party until 2009. In these states, Democrats successfully advocated for the lottery by promising the funds to education and scholarships, which were popular issues.

Even legislators who opposed gambling were persuaded by the fact that many of their constituents were buying tickets in nearby states where the lottery was legal. Seeing all that revenue escape across state lines was a powerful (and painful) motivator.

"The lottery issue is a great lesson in how policies spread," Nelson said. "Sometimes a state has a great idea and other states copy it. Sometimes a state has a terrible idea, but other states adopt it to avoid being left out."

Alabama, too, tried to start up a lottery in the late '90s. Democratic Gov. Donald Siegelman campaigned on this issue, promising that the money would fund students at Alabama's colleges. This would copy Georgia's HOPE scholarships, which are supported by lottery funds. But like many states, Alabama had a constitutional ban on lotteries and to amend it required citizens to approve lotteries in a referendum vote. In 1999, the measure came up for a vote, but religious groups mounted a fierce campaign to keep the lottery out of Alabama. In the end, the proposal failed, with 54 percent of Alabamians voting against the lottery.

Now the state is in more desperate straits. With most of its budget tricks spent, the state needs real money or else faces real cuts. Prisons and Medicaid are the largest obligations, and already both are meagerly funded. The state's prisons hold nearly twice as many inmates as they were designed for. The state's hospital association says over a dozen rural hospitals have closed because too many patients come in without health insurance. The governor says would support Medicaid expansion, but only if Alabama could require recipients to work. This is unpalatable provision for the Obama administration.

So the situation in Alabama has become a three-way standoff. The governor wants tax increases; other politicians in his party are calling for harsher budget cuts. Meanwhile, Democrats are hawking the lottery, an idea they have tried to peddle for years.

Bentley doesn't oppose a lottery but he also points out that it would take years before citizens could approve it and the infrastructure could be set up. This morning, in an unusual move for a Republican governor, Bentley delivered a paean to taxes.

"We have to pay for the services we expect," he said. "You can't have a cellphone without paying for it. You can't drive your car without paying for gas. Everything we own in this state – this building, the roads, Montgomery — somebody paid a tax to build it."

And yet, Bentley overlooks that throughout much of U.S. history, lotteries have also been used to paid for these things. Soon, Alabama residents may again be asked if they will allow this controversial practice to return.

Washington Post, Lottery Post Staff

We'd love to see your comments here!  Register for a FREE membership — it takes just a few moments — and you'll be able to post comments here and on any of our forums. If you're already a member, you can Log In to post a comment.

23 comments. Last comment 2 years ago by darthfury78.
Page 1 of 2
Technut's avatar - moon
3rd Rock from Sun
United States
Member #159103
September 13, 2014
151 Posts
Offline
Posted: April 20, 2015, 11:17 pm - IP Logged

Sooner or later the the citizens will face facts of more taxes or allow a lottery.  Most cases they end up opting for lottery over taxes but time will tell.

Yesterday is History, Tomorrow is a Mystery, Today is a gift that's why it's called the PRESENT! (c8

    Avatar

    United States
    Member #122691
    February 6, 2012
    330 Posts
    Offline
    Posted: April 21, 2015, 4:40 am - IP Logged

    When Christianity meets reality. 

      Nikkicute's avatar - nnjx1k
      Wisconsin
      United States
      Member #123290
      February 17, 2012
      3052 Posts
      Online
      Posted: April 21, 2015, 4:59 am - IP Logged

      Sweet home Alabama!! Bring on the lottery! More money in the pot if they add powerball/megamillions.

        Bondi Junction
        Australia
        Member #57242
        December 24, 2007
        1102 Posts
        Offline
        Posted: April 21, 2015, 7:24 am - IP Logged

        It is only a matter of time before Alabama has a lottery. Until then Alabamian can play a lottery, the Massachusetts Megabucks Doubler game by subscription. It is a bit of fun.

        We all get a lot out of lotteries!

          Gleno's avatar - Lottery-001.jpg
          New Jersey
          United States
          Member #80354
          September 25, 2009
          705 Posts
          Offline
          Posted: April 21, 2015, 7:39 am - IP Logged

          Will they use the lottery profits to fund public employee pensions? 

           What?

           

          The lottery may help their finances but doubt it.

           

          Most states are having problems with financing of public employees health benefits  and retirement funds.

           

          Any discussion about reforming the public employee's benefits is met with angry opposition by public employee unions.

           

          Could you imagine the uproar if their retirement benefits were to be transferred to the federal level of  the Social Security System that most workers are required

          to pay into during their working years?

           

          Argue

            OldSchoolPa's avatar - Lottery-057.jpg
            Gurnee, Illinois
            United States
            Member #49731
            February 12, 2007
            917 Posts
            Offline
            Posted: April 21, 2015, 9:26 am - IP Logged

            When Christianity meets reality. 

            The Bible does not forbid gambling since drawing lots was a common practice. It has been preachers greed and twisting of Bible to benefit their own interests that has led to religious opposition to lotteries. Note how preachers will rail against Christians who spend money playing the lottery but will be the first ones coming with their hands out palms facing up seeking the man-ordained money tithe! Hypocrites and ravenous wolves they are.

            Get MONEY!!! Winning a JACKPOT lottery is all the HOPE and CHANGE I desire!!!  NOW give me MONEY!US Flag

            The guy who won the presidency in 2008 really won the lottery...he is now millions richer, travels in first class style, and even has a staff that would be the envy of the richest Powerball winner (she has a staff of 2). Every night he goes to sleep, he probably plays the close of Dave Chappelle's Show: I'm rich beyatch!

              pcurtis's avatar - DiscoBallGlowing
              fayetteville tn
              United States
              Member #68983
              January 3, 2009
              1829 Posts
              Offline
              Posted: April 21, 2015, 11:04 am - IP Logged

              I will play it instead of TN lottery! If it passes.

              Tn lottery sucks

                zephbe's avatar - animal butterfly.jpg
                South Carolina
                United States
                Member #77167
                July 15, 2009
                555 Posts
                Offline
                Posted: April 21, 2015, 1:26 pm - IP Logged

                An Alabama man went back home extra happy after winning $450,000 from a Georgia lottery instant ticket--March 24, 2015

                Frank Guthrie, 55, from Seale, AL claimed his $1 million prize on Jan. 27, after winning the prize from the $10 Million Cash Spectacular instant game.

                 An Alabama man has claimed a $54,000 prize for a winning Florida Lottery Fantasy 5 ticket sold last week at a Nine Mile Road store

                MONTGOMERY, AL (WSFA) -A Montgomery woman is now a multimillionaire after buying the winning ticket for Florida's biggest jackpot of the year.

                Carolyn Bell, 64, claimed the $48 million FLORIDA LOTTO® jackpot from the drawing held on November 19, 2014.

                Alabama not having a lottery isn't stopping any one from winning money in neighboring states.

                Every champion was once a contender who refused to give up.-Rocky Balboa

                “Don’t let someone who gave up on their dreams talk you out of going after yours.” – Zig Ziglar

                  TnTicketlosers's avatar - Lottery-065.jpg

                  United States
                  Member #71120
                  February 19, 2009
                  1209 Posts
                  Offline
                  Posted: April 21, 2015, 3:09 pm - IP Logged

                  Come on Alabama start the lottery so I can cross the line,Alabama people will stop playing on the """"Miracle Mile""""Only thing on that mile is scammers  running the stores.They have their friends playing $1.00 scratch offs,,,,you play $20.00 ones,,,,you dont get a hit in 8 of them,they call up their friends to buy the next 2 or 3 tickets...bunch of cheaters in Tennessee,,,,pissed me off,wouldnt you be?

                    Avatar
                    Kentucky
                    United States
                    Member #32652
                    February 14, 2006
                    7313 Posts
                    Offline
                    Posted: April 21, 2015, 5:22 pm - IP Logged

                    It is only a matter of time before Alabama has a lottery. Until then Alabamian can play a lottery, the Massachusetts Megabucks Doubler game by subscription. It is a bit of fun.

                    Bentley doesn't oppose a lottery but he also points out that it would take years before citizens could approve it and the infrastructure could be set up.

                    Did you miss where it says "it would take years"?

                      HaveABall's avatar - rocket

                      United States
                      Member #72448
                      March 18, 2009
                      1228 Posts
                      Offline
                      Posted: April 21, 2015, 5:51 pm - IP Logged

                      Sooner or later the the citizens will face facts of more taxes or allow a lottery.  Most cases they end up opting for lottery over taxes but time will tell.

                      I Agree!, Technut! 

                      Since hiring an Ace Bookeeper, then requiring all legislature notions/concepts/plans and government contracts to vendors get approved through this Bookeeper FIRST doesn't make sense for this state or any other state within the good 'ole U.S. of A.

                      Having several millions of dollars in my financial accounts means receiving several valuable services each day!

                      Disney

                        music*'s avatar - nw bookeep.jpg
                        Happy California
                        United States
                        Member #157856
                        August 2, 2014
                        1520 Posts
                        Offline
                        Posted: April 21, 2015, 6:52 pm - IP Logged

                         More freedom for the people. Please treat us like adults.

                          Epistrophy's avatar - Lottery-042.jpg
                          San Diego, CA
                          United States
                          Member #112369
                          June 17, 2011
                          187 Posts
                          Offline
                          Posted: April 21, 2015, 11:47 pm - IP Logged

                          In Birmingham they love the governor

                          Now we all did what we could do

                          Powerball does not bother me

                          Does your conscience bother you?

                          Tell the truth

                            RedStang's avatar - tallman zps6gf4inoc.jpg
                            NY
                            United States
                            Member #121961
                            January 21, 2012
                            3157 Posts
                            Offline
                            Posted: April 22, 2015, 1:08 am - IP Logged

                            They should of thought about this when there use to be large jackpots and revenue was pouring in.