instant scratch-off through a vending machine that had cut it in half due to a malfunction.

Oh great here we go again. He is screwed. The lottery is going to spin this so they are not at fault.

It is unclear why he filed the lawsuit in Cook County rather than in Lake County

Watch the judge will throw out the lawsuit saying it is in the wrong county. What if lake county does not have a court that handles things like this.

Carlos is ready to do battle : got himself a lawyer. He's got exhibits, probably has a portion of the original ticket as well. Carlos is taking this serious.So far Kelly has nothing, he's presented nothing. By all accounts, Carlos is loaded for bear. Should be an interesting case.On paper : Round one to Carlos, for preparedness.

 * I'm still waiting to find out what happened to the case of the dad sending his underage kid in to a store to purchase a million dollar plus winning scratcher ticket..

The article doesn't make clear whether the Illinois Lottery initially accepted the million dollar claim. If yes, that raises some questions. 1. Why would they accept a claim for a ticket that's cut in half. 2. Did they acknowledge the instant ticket machine malfunctioned. 3. Why didn't they investigate the sale further, such as viewing video - many lotteries do for top prize winners, especially when there are suspected irregularities.

Again, this illustrates why lottery retailers and its employees should not be permitted to buy / play tickets at their own location(s). Lotteries, by and large, seemingly don't care. Shame, since that one change alone would eliminate much of these problems.

Assuming the IL Lottery initially accepted the claim, the lawsuit likely has merit and it will be up to the court to decide who gets the winnings.

The CA underage winner case (father sending kid in to cash winners for more tickets) is a whole different matter. From all indications, that lawsuit is extremely unlikely to be successful due to the seemingly iron-clad CA Lottery rules regarding underage gambling.

"Why would they accept a claim for a ticket that's cut in half."

The ticket wasn't printed in error and doesn't have any other original defect that should make it invalid. It's just a winning ticket that was damaged, so the only issue should be whether or not it can be validated despite the damage. If half of a ticket is enough to establish that it's a winner I don't see any logical reason for denying payment other than the possibility that the rules would let them deny it.

Based on the claims in the complaint it sounds like the CVS employee only has one half of the ticket, so at the very least the lottery should be doing an investigation before paying anybody. The complaint also says that the ticket "came in two halves", so the customer presumably got, and still has the other half. That probably means he's got a pretty good case since his argument for why the employee has half of the ticket is probably better than any argument the employee can come up with about why the customer would have half of a ticket belonging to the employee.

Solomon would give each of them 500K.  Case closed.

Interested to see how this one turns out. People really need to check their own tickets. I would never let anyone coerce me into handing them my ticket damaged or not. I think he has a decent case. When lottery officials investigate they will see what transpired on the tape. Unless that tape has somehow been deleted. How else would the employee think they could get away with this? I am amazed that people still play the lottery in Illinois. Didn't they have trouble with payouts to winners?

If Solomon was an Illinois Lottery official he'd find a way to say neither gets the money.

You got that right! If someone else ever has my lottery tickets other than a Lottery Agent at the Claims Office(s), I won't even fathom. Just know that my tickets, scratch-offs included, are signed before I leave the store. You will NEVER. find an unsigned lottery ticket on me. Also, I only throw away my non-winning tickets at home and keep them in a TX Lottery bag for up to a Year before tossing them out. TAKE PRECAUTIONS!!!  I treat MY tickets like MONEY when I purchase them because I expect to WIN, WIN, WIN!!!!

Figueroa then claims that he was "coerced" by a CVS employee into handing him half of the ticket under the ruse of checking if it was a winner

If he had both halves or just the bottom half, he could still scratch the bar code and scan the ticket. I'd have to be "coerced" at the business end of a gun before I'd hand over a lottery ticket possibly worth $1 million. 

Just a guess, but it doesn't look like Figueroa is very lottery savvy.

Let's muddy the water a bit Stack. Let's for argument sake say, that Carlos is an illegal immigrant, and has now hit it big. Besides being non lottery savvy, he's reaching out to Kelly and asking " for help"- check my ticket and tell me if l won? Perhaps Kelly is hoping for ICE to swoop down and round up Carlos. Thing is, Carlos wouldn't mind being picked up, just as long as he knows he has major walking around money.

Just saying.....

       excellent post!

I am having trouble believing this story

The part about being coerced into having ticket checked and waiting 20 minutes seems absurd especially since scanners are there for customers to check tickets at counters and if worker checks it behind counter he would be able to watch it and it wouldn't take 20 minutes

Something isn't right with this story

.. which is why l am going with the illegal alien bit. It may sound far fetched, but the possibility exists. 

The last time I looked, Carlos hasn't collected a dime and if ICE swoops down, he'll be walking around with whatever he had. The ticket was cut in half horizonally and the bar code is on the bottom. Carlos could have scanned it and then taken it to lottery headquarters.

If Carlos still has the top half of the ticket and it shows a $1 million winner, all bets are off.