Welcome Guest
Log In | Register )
You last visited December 7, 2016, 7:02 pm
All times shown are
Eastern Time (GMT-5:00)

Anti-lottery group sues to end Mega Millions in California

Mega MillionsMega Millions: Anti-lottery group sues to end Mega Millions in California

The California Coalition Against Gambling Expansion filed a lawsuit Wednesday seeking an injunction to shut down the state's two-week-old Mega Millions multistate lotto.

The coalition will formally notified the California State Lottery of the action Wednesday, and then publicly announced it in a press release [see below], the group's attorneys from the Sacramento and Woodland Hills areas told Lottery Post.

The coalition, represented by Sacramento-area attorney Fred Jones and Woodland Hills business law attorney Nicholas Roxborough, made the announcement at a 10 a.m. news conference at the Capitol.

The lawsuit rose out of allegations that the 12-state game is unconstitutional because it operates beyond California and was approved without adequate public review.

The Governor's Office referred phone calls for reaction to the lottery, where a spokeswoman said the acting director, Chon Gutierrez, refused to "speculate" about the lawsuit until it was filed.

The lottery disclosed, however, that $16.5 million Mega Millions has hiked overall sales by about $9 million. But most of that — $7 million — came from players switching from California's ongoing Super Lotto Plus.

The coalition's lawsuit "requests the court immediately cease Mega Millions in California," Jones said. "Participation in the game clearly violates explicit provisions of the Lottery Act."

Voters made the act part of the state constitution in 1984.

The coalition wants voters to consider any Lottery Act changes even though the Legislature can alter the games on a two-thirds vote with the governor's concurrence. Gutierrez, a Schwarzenegger administration troubleshooter, launched the game June 22 with the approval of a policy-setting commission largely appointed by the Republican governor, who views it as a deficit-easing device.

In Mega Millions, players pay $1 to pick five numbers from 1 to 56, and one number from 1 to 46, to match those drawn twice weekly.  Bets in California are pooled with the existing Mega Millions states of New York, Texas, Massachusetts, Michigan, Ohio, Maryland, Georgia, Illinois, New Jersey, Virginia, and Washington.

Mega Millions results and other information can be found on the web site, www.usamega.com.


California Citizens Sue Mega Millions Lottery

Full text of press release

A Petition for Writ of Mandate was filed late yesterday [Editor: Wednesday] afternoon in the Sacramento Superior Court, seeking an injunction to shut down the state's Mega Millions multi-state lottery game. The Petition challenges the California Lottery Commission's authority under Proposition 37, passed by the voters in 1984, and its unilateral decision to join the multi-state lottery game without obtaining the required legislative approval.

"This action has nothing to do with the policy merits of state-sponsored lotteries and everything to do with the funding of our education system and fundamental democratic procedures," explains Nicholas Roxborough, a partner of Los Angeles-based Roxborough, Pomerance & Nye LLP, one of the attorneys who filed the suit on behalf of the plaintiffs which include a teacher and citizen organizations concerned that the public and their elected representatives must be consulted before allowing interstate expansion of California's lottery. "We are challenging the notion that the California Lottery Commission, or for that matter, any administrative body of our state government, cannot unilaterally delegate key duties imposed on it through the initiative process, while at the same time trying to avoid its accountability to our elected representatives."

The lawsuit was filed as a last resort after an emergency legislative hearing on June 16 to delay the launch proved unsuccessful, with the Legislative Counsel's Office and the Attorney General's Office sticking to their conflicting legal positions. The Legislature's legal counsel has firmly and publicly opined that the Commission lacked the legal authority to join the Mega Millions lottery while the Attorney General's Office, upon the request of the Commission, issued two "informal" confidential advice letters concluding the Commission probably had the implied authority to do so.

"These 'informal' advice letters from the Attorney General's office rely upon an inappropriate stretch of Joint Powers authority granted to all state agencies," Roxborough explains. "Moreover, these letters were not the result of any public discussion or input, as they appear to be a private communication between the Commission and the Attorney General's Office."

The lawsuit is based on the premise that the California Lottery Commission never notified or sought the approval of the Legislature, nor considered going to the voters for explicit authority to join the Mega Millions lottery as originally required by Proposition 37. The plaintiffs allege the Commission intended to stifle public notice and debate by its lack of appropriate disclosure, evidenced by the fact that the Commission devoted only a single public hearing on the matter, after giving less than two business days notice on a Friday afternoon.

"With the exception of New Jersey, which has provided sweeping powers to their state lottery, all other eleven Mega Millions states have explicit statutes authorizing states to participate in multi-state lotteries," says Sacramento-based attorney Fred Jones who jointly filed the suit with Roxborough. "California should not be the exception. Our voters have the right to determine whether or not our participation in this multi-state venture serves the interests of California's education system and citizens."

Proponents of the California State Lottery Act of 1984 assured voters the lottery would be strictly limited to and administrated only by California; voters never contemplated they were authorizing a multi-state or international lottery, Jones explains. However, the contract signed by the Commission Director relinquishes key operational authority over California ticket revenues to out-of-state administrators and tickets are sold by vendors unlicensed and unregulated by California officials, in direct violation by the California Lottery Act.

"While Commission officials have assured that Prop 37's mandate to provide 34 cents of every dollar wagered to public education will be honored in the Mega Millions lottery, it will be impossible to enforce the strict financial accountability provision of Prop 37 in this multi-state venture," says Jones.

The benefit of the Mega Millions venture to increase education funding in California is also questioned by plaintiffs.

"We've already seen the Lottery Commission sponsor legislation to reduce Prop 37 guarantees to public education on several occasions in the past three years," says Antonio Mendoza, one of the plaintiffs named in the lawsuit. "And, the Commission Director has publicly stated that any savings in overhead expenses by transferring operational authority to other Mega Million states will not be passed onto schools."

"We hope this lawsuit will force the Commission to bring this issue into the public arena where it belongs," adds Jim Butler, executive director of the California Coalition Against Gambling Expansion, another plaintiff. "We would like California citizens to have the opportunity to vote on this issue and determine whether or not the Mega Millions lottery game will be in the state's best interests."

Roxborough, Pomerance & Nye LLP (RPN) is a Los Angeles-based law firm providing expert legal counsel and representation to the California business community. Established in 1995, the firm offers abroad range of legal services in all facets of civil litigation, with its primary focus on litigation, legislation and policy making issues involving insurance and business related concerns.

The law offices of Fred Jones are located in the Sacramento region, providing legal and public policy services to clients since 1998. The firm primarily focuses on civil litigation, estate planning and state legislative lobbying.

Lottery Post Staff

We'd love to see your comments here!  Register for a FREE membership — it takes just a few moments — and you'll be able to post comments here and on any of our forums. If you're already a member, you can Log In to post a comment.

33 comments. Last comment 11 years ago by LOTTOMIKE.
Page 1 of 3
Avatar
New Mexico
United States
Member #12305
March 10, 2005
2984 Posts
Offline
Posted: July 8, 2005, 11:17 am - IP Logged

"We hope this lawsuit will force the Commission to bring this issue into the public arena where it belongs," adds Jim Butler, executive director of the California Coalition Against Gambling Expansion, another plaintiff. "We would like California citizens to have the opportunity to vote on this issue and determine whether or not the Mega Millions lottery game will be in the state's best interests."

Difficult to find fault with that sentiment, though I suspect the group won't be happy with the results of a referendum.  But maybe they're actually just monkey-wrenching.... if they lose a referendum, they find something else to contest.  I've got a gut feeling the group couldn't care less what the voters and citizens want, unless they happen to want not to gamble.

Jack

 

    atlasshrugged's avatar - candle
    Alaska
    United States
    Member #16217
    May 27, 2005
    287 Posts
    Offline
    Posted: July 8, 2005, 11:26 am - IP Logged

    I am in agreement with Rip. It seems to be another case of one group of folks trying to tell another group of folks what to do with their money. I just wish people would start cleaning around thier own back door and let others do the same. -Bonnie

      konane's avatar - wallace
      Atlanta, GA
      United States
      Member #1265
      March 13, 2003
      3333 Posts
      Offline
      Posted: July 8, 2005, 12:07 pm - IP Logged

      Agree with you both and hope they remember their politicians positions on the matter when it comes time to vote.        Yes Nod

      Good luck to everyone!


        United States
        Member #17649
        June 24, 2005
        11 Posts
        Offline
        Posted: July 8, 2005, 2:05 pm - IP Logged

        I swear to god, i'm so tired of people saying "let's put it in front of the people, let the people decide" the reason we have a republica and not a pure democracy is because the people are STUPID.  i.e. gay marriage...if one more conservative says put it up to a people's vote, i'm going to die.  i bet if we put it up to the people, they'd vote to ship every gay person off to the first moon colony if enough adds were run advocating that.....

         

        but back on topic.....i hope they cut them off right before the drawing and a ticket was a winner in ca, i will laugh my butt off

          Avatar
          New Mexico
          United States
          Member #12305
          March 10, 2005
          2984 Posts
          Offline
          Posted: July 8, 2005, 2:12 pm - IP Logged

          I swear to god, i'm so tired of people saying "let's put it in front of the people, let the people decide" the reason we have a republica and not a pure democracy is because the people are STUPID.  i.e. gay marriage...if one more conservative says put it up to a people's vote, i'm going to die.  i bet if we put it up to the people, they'd vote to ship every gay person off to the first moon colony if enough adds were run advocating that.....

           

          but back on topic.....i hope they cut them off right before the drawing and a ticket was a winner in ca, i will laugh my butt off

          Hmmmmm.  I don't think I can qualify as a conservative, but I'm willing to try.

          Let's put it in front of the people, let the people decide.

          Bon voyage, amigo.

          (How's things down on 4th Street, Killeen,  these days?)

          Jack

            JAP69's avatar - alas
            South Carolina
            United States
            Member #6
            November 4, 2001
            8790 Posts
            Online
            Posted: July 8, 2005, 2:16 pm - IP Logged

            The pro mega million players should file a lawsuit against the anti mega million group.............................

            MAGA

              Todd's avatar - Cylon 2.gif
              Chief Bottle Washer
              New Jersey
              United States
              Member #1
              May 31, 2000
              23267 Posts
              Offline
              Posted: July 8, 2005, 2:18 pm - IP Logged

              I swear to god, i'm so tired of people saying "let's put it in front of the people, let the people decide" the reason we have a republica and not a pure democracy is because the people are STUPID.  i.e. gay marriage...if one more conservative says put it up to a people's vote, i'm going to die.  i bet if we put it up to the people, they'd vote to ship every gay person off to the first moon colony if enough adds were run advocating that.....

               

              but back on topic.....i hope they cut them off right before the drawing and a ticket was a winner in ca, i will laugh my butt off

              I agree with Jack, let's put it in front of the people, let the people decide.

              Why don't you move to North Korea, where they recognize that "the people are STUPID" (your words), so the leaders decide for them.

              You don't sound very well thought out.  You say you understand our political system, but obviously you don't.  The reason for our republic form of democracy is not because of "stupid people", but because a pure democracy would be logistically impossible to operate with a country of this size.

              This is a "government of the people", and I guess that infuriates radical left-wingers.

               

              Check the State Lottery Report Card
              What grade did your lottery earn?

               

              Sign the Petition for True Lottery Drawings
              Help eliminate computerized drawings!

                Avatar
                New York, NY
                United States
                Member #13514
                April 7, 2005
                235 Posts
                Offline
                Posted: July 8, 2005, 2:36 pm - IP Logged

                The pro mega million players should file a lawsuit against the anti mega million group.............................

                I agree.

                 

                The game is already going on, if you don't like to gamble.....THEN DON'T!!!!  Geesh.  Rant 


                  United States
                  Member #17649
                  June 24, 2005
                  11 Posts
                  Offline
                  Posted: July 8, 2005, 3:11 pm - IP Logged

                  I swear to god, i'm so tired of people saying "let's put it in front of the people, let the people decide" the reason we have a republica and not a pure democracy is because the people are STUPID.  i.e. gay marriage...if one more conservative says put it up to a people's vote, i'm going to die.  i bet if we put it up to the people, they'd vote to ship every gay person off to the first moon colony if enough adds were run advocating that.....

                   

                  but back on topic.....i hope they cut them off right before the drawing and a ticket was a winner in ca, i will laugh my butt off

                  I agree with Jack, let's put it in front of the people, let the people decide.

                  Why don't you move to North Korea, where they recognize that "the people are STUPID" (your words), so the leaders decide for them.

                  You don't sound very well thought out.  You say you understand our political system, but obviously you don't.  The reason for our republic form of democracy is not because of "stupid people", but because a pure democracy would be logistically impossible to operate with a country of this size.

                  This is a "government of the people", and I guess that infuriates radical left-wingers.

                  well...actually no...the reason we have a republic and not a pure democracy is because the founding fathers wanted to protect minority rights from the crazed majority.  I.E. you telling people to move to north korea cause you don't agree with their political views.  Perhaps you should move to north korea instead since you seem to sound a little fascist....

                   

                  p.s. the country wasn't nearly this big when it was founded and the constitution was written, so "but because a pure democracy would be logistically impossible to operate with a country of this size." is just sheer stupidity, though today if this country were being founded that might be a logical argument.

                    Todd's avatar - Cylon 2.gif
                    Chief Bottle Washer
                    New Jersey
                    United States
                    Member #1
                    May 31, 2000
                    23267 Posts
                    Offline
                    Posted: July 8, 2005, 3:20 pm - IP Logged

                    If I sound fascist, then you certainly sound socialist.

                    There are many reasons why we have a representative democracy, and the reason I explained to you is one of the key ones.

                    You don't seem to understand what a true democracy is, if you think the original 13 colonies could logistically be run with a true democracy.

                    Even ancient Greece, as a very tiny country, suffered from its true Democracy.

                    Grow up, and stop throwing labels like "fascist" at every person who doesn't agree with your liberal agenda.

                     

                    Check the State Lottery Report Card
                    What grade did your lottery earn?

                     

                    Sign the Petition for True Lottery Drawings
                    Help eliminate computerized drawings!


                      United States
                      Member #17649
                      June 24, 2005
                      11 Posts
                      Offline
                      Posted: July 8, 2005, 3:23 pm - IP Logged

                      If I sound fascist, then you certainly sound socialist.

                      There are many reasons why we have a representative democracy, and the reason I explained to you is one of the key ones.

                      You don't seem to understand what a true democracy is, if you think the original 13 colonies could logistically be run with a true democracy.

                      Even ancient Greece, as a very tiny country, suffered from its true Democracy.

                      Grow up, and stop throwing labels like "fascist" at every person who doesn't agree with your liberal agenda.

                      hmm? hmm? what's that smell??? smells like hypocrite to me!!!

                       

                      mr. i'm going to label you a radical left-winger based on one sentence....hahahahaha....how about you grow up first? 

                       

                      and what liberal agenda did  i put out there btw?  to keep gays from being shipped off to the moon? oh yeah....how lame of me....where's my space suit...i need to get in line

                        Todd's avatar - Cylon 2.gif
                        Chief Bottle Washer
                        New Jersey
                        United States
                        Member #1
                        May 31, 2000
                        23267 Posts
                        Offline
                        Posted: July 8, 2005, 3:24 pm - IP Logged

                        I seem to have touched a nerve.

                         

                        Check the State Lottery Report Card
                        What grade did your lottery earn?

                         

                        Sign the Petition for True Lottery Drawings
                        Help eliminate computerized drawings!


                          United States
                          Member #17649
                          June 24, 2005
                          11 Posts
                          Offline
                          Posted: July 8, 2005, 3:26 pm - IP Logged

                          p.s. the point i was making, which you obviously don't seem to get, is that some things, shouldn't be up to the people, period.  slavery, shouldn't be up for a vote, equal rights for women and gays, shouldn't be up for a vote.  these are things that should be absolute, through and through....and your oh so lame "i think i hit a nerve" line, stemming from the fact you have no cognotive retort, is quite...oh what's the word, stupid.

                            Todd's avatar - Cylon 2.gif
                            Chief Bottle Washer
                            New Jersey
                            United States
                            Member #1
                            May 31, 2000
                            23267 Posts
                            Offline
                            Posted: July 8, 2005, 3:28 pm - IP Logged

                            Everything should be up to the people.

                             

                            Check the State Lottery Report Card
                            What grade did your lottery earn?

                             

                            Sign the Petition for True Lottery Drawings
                            Help eliminate computerized drawings!