Welcome Guest
Log In | Register )
You last visited October 21, 2020, 5:45 am
All times shown are
Eastern Time (GMT-5:00)

California Lottery settles lawsuits with two former security staff

Oct 9, 2018, 9:25 am

Share this news story on Facebook
Tweet this news story on Twitter
California LotteryCalifornia Lottery: California Lottery settles lawsuits with two former security staffRating:

Employees were fired for questioning two jackpot payouts

The California State Lottery has paid more than $500,000 to settle lawsuits filed by two former investigators who claimed they were fired for calling attention to jackpots they believed the lottery improperly awarded to recipients who could not prove they were winners.

The two ousted lottery cops had flagged a $2 million jackpot in 2015 and a $750,000 prize in 2016 that they argued should not have been paid.

"It was a travesty the way they were both handled," said Steve Tacchini, a retired San Francisco police captain and former lottery deputy director. A third and related lawsuit from another former investigator is still in play.

The ongoing costs to taxpayers stem from discipline the lottery handed down two years ago when a group of investigators grew frustrated by what they considered to be preventable fraud among lottery retailers as well as questionable payouts.

Between Tacchini and three subordinates, the former employees attempted to raise concerns about the payouts with the attorney general, state auditor and a reporter at the CBS station in Los Angeles.

They say their punishment sent a chilling message to other employees.

"I don't regret doing what was right, but there are so many people who just don't say anything," said Gary Reid Galbreath, one of the employees who sued the department after his dismissal in 2017.

The four worked in the lottery's Security and Law Enforcement Division, a branch of the department charged with conducting background checks on employees and lottery retailers, as well as investigating lottery-related crimes. Under Tacchini, the division favored an attention-grabbing approach to enforcement, including stings against retailers.

"They didn't like us because we arrested people," said Helen Brean, a former chief lottery agent who sued the department after her dismissal. "We put them in handcuffs. We got in the news, and that told people that retailers were crooked."

In written statements, the lottery declined to discuss personnel disputes. It said the totality of evidence in the cases the former employees contested supported the department's decisions to pay the jackpots. 

A ticketless winner

The case that most severely split the the lottery's law enforcement arm under Tacchini and its executive staff involved a Beverly Hills man who lost a Powerball ticket but believed he was the winner of a $2 million prize.

Investigative records show the man bought a ticket in January 2015. No one claimed the prize. The lottery contacted the gas station where the man bought the ticket to figure out who deserved the jackpot.

After looking at surveillance footage, the retailer and lottery officials identified one of the store's regular customers as the winner.

In June 2015, the gas station owner told the man he won the Powerball. He filed a claim to obtain it as a "ticketless" winner.

Images from surveillance video were not sufficient because the camera's timing was not set correctly and other people bought tickets within minutes of his purchase. That meant the presumptive winner had to present additional evidence to demonstrate he bought the ticket.

Brean conducted the lottery's final interview with him in July 2015. He told her he paid for his usual $6 bet when he bought his lottery ticket that day, according to a report The Bee obtained through the California Public Records Act. Lottery records showed that the winning ticket was a $20 wager.

"There was nothing. If the information he gave was accurate, there was no way he could be the winner," Brean said.

Against her recommendation, the lottery paid the jackpot and said it stands by its decision.

Brean was suspended soon after her report. The lottery moved to fire her in June 2016.

Brean filed her lawsuit on Aug. 11, 2016. The Lottery settled with her within a week. She received 18 months pay, about $150,000.

Tacchini, too, opposed paying the man. The governor's office ended Tacchini's appointment as a deputy director in May 2016 and brought in a new law enforcement team led by California Highway Patrol officers.

Down the ranks

The departures of Brean and Tacchini alarmed at least two of their subordinates.

By then, Galbreath and fellow investigator Jim Jeffra had grown frustrated by what they viewed as preventable fraud among retailers. They wanted the lottery to invest in new technology that might give the department an early warning if retailers turned in a suspicious number of winning tickets, which could signal that they were finding winning Scratchers and keeping them for themselves.

Galbreath also was disturbed, although there was no evidence of fraud, by a lottery decision to pay a $750,000 prize to a San Francisco small business owner who had given money to an employee for lottery tickets.

The worker bought the ticket, scratched it and checked that it was a winner at retail stores. By lottery rules, he "exercised the acts of ownership" and could have claimed the prize. The worker was an undocumented immigrant who did not want to claim the winnings, according to documents The Bee obtained through the Public Records Act.

The business owner gave conflicting statements to the lottery about claiming the prize, according to a lottery investigation. Ultimately, he and his employee suggested that they wanted the owner to claim it. The lottery agreed to pay the owner despite an initial recommendation from a lottery investigator against awarding him the money.

About that time, Galbreath and Jeffra each separately called the state auditor. They talked, and decided to write a joint complaint to the auditor urging an investigation into the lottery itself. 

They knew Brean had contacted the state auditor and Tacchini had reached out to the attorney general prior to losing their lottery jobs. They worried they'd be dismissed, too, if word got out that they were calling for an investigation, according to court records.

Galbreath downloaded lottery investigations to give to the auditors. Then, he decided to contact a reporter at KCAL in Los Angeles who had covered lottery fraud in the past.

'Bringing embarrassment to your employer'

The KCAL pieces aired in October 2016. Brean and Tacchini spoke on camera, alleging that the lottery was paying prizes inappropriately. 

Galbreath and Jeffra spoke, too. The news program concealed their identities by disguising their faces and voices.

CHP Assistant Chief James Libby opened an investigation into the CBS report and placed Galbreath and Jeffra on administrative leave. The department checked who had looked at the files; records pointed to the two investigators.

Both sat for interviews with Kelly Dixon, Libby's special assistant, in November 2016. Galbreath and Jeffra denied handing records to the reporter; they said they downloaded the reports for the auditor.

"You clearly accessed data owned by the lottery that you were directed not to access. In addition to that, both of you appeared on a news program in which you make some allegations that members of the lottery are doing things that are in violation of law, regulation statute. Why did you do this?" Dixon said when he interviewed Jeffra.

Jeffra replied, "For three and a half years, I've been told, 'Oh they're working on it.' I've been lied to. They're not working on anything."

Dixon asked both former investigators whether they intended to discredit or embarrass the lottery by appearing on the news program. "We have a policy about bringing embarrassment to your employer," he said, citing a state law that permits discipline of public employees.

"My intention was not to damage the reputation of the lottery in any way," Galbreath said, according to the 2016 transcript. "My intention was to simply try to go back to having that sense of pride that I had in my employer when I first started."

Dixon at the hearings said the investigators did not have the full picture of evidence available to lottery executives.

"While he has an opinion, and everybody's entitled to opinion, that opinion isn't based on all of the facts when that decision at the executive management level was made to pay or not pay a client," he said.

'The risk I took'

Shortly after his interview with Dixon, Jeffra submitted retirement paperwork. Galbreath remained on administrative leave until April 2017, when the department served him with a dismissal notice. It accused him of conducting an "unauthorized investigation" and disseminating confidential information to the public.

Galbreath appealed his dismissal and filed a lawsuit contesting it in August 2017. The department settled with him two months later. He received $375,000, a sum equivalent to about five years of his salary.

Jeffra filed his lawsuit in January of this year with the same attorney who represented Galbreath. The attorney did not respond to requests for comment. The case has not settled and the department has moved to dismiss it.

Galbreath now works as an investigator for a health insurance company. Brean is retired in Rosevelle.

Galbreath acknowledged he received a substantial settlement to drop his lawsuit, but he's had trouble breaking into another law enforcement job since he left the lottery. He discloses on his applications that he was the subject of a whistleblower investigation.

"You're definitely labeled when you put it out there, and that was the risk I took," he said.

Sacramento Bee

We'd love to see your comments here!  Register for a FREE membership — it takes just a few moments — and you'll be able to post comments here and on any of our forums. If you're already a member, you can Log In to post a comment.

10 comments. Last comment 2 years ago by music*.
Page 1 of 1
Avatar
Chasing $ Millions.
White Shores- California
United States
Member #136473
December 12, 2012
6336 Posts
Offline

"Ticketless" jackpot winner? How is that even possible?

 * Voice of Reason *   

 

People who say it cannot be done should not interrupt those who are doing it- George Bernard Shaw.

    Avatar
    Chasing $ Millions.
    White Shores- California
    United States
    Member #136473
    December 12, 2012
    6336 Posts
    Offline

    Just got to thinking, given the department's " payback" procedures- those "whistleblowers" who took pictures at the lottery party two years ago, and want people fired. They better watch it, if they get canned, it should come as no surprise.l warned them..

    Just saying, l mean look here...

     * Voice of Reason *   

     

    People who say it cannot be done should not interrupt those who are doing it- George Bernard Shaw.

      CDanaT's avatar - Nolz june15.jpg
      Central TN
      United States
      Member #121189
      January 4, 2012
      4772 Posts
      Offline

      California................That one word says it all  Crazy

      Integrity: There is just no substitute.

        Avatar
        DMV
        United States
        Member #183847
        August 18, 2017
        284 Posts
        Offline

        Just got to thinking, given the department's " payback" procedures- those "whistleblowers" who took pictures at the lottery party two years ago, and want people fired. They better watch it, if they get canned, it should come as no surprise.l warned them..

        Just saying, l mean look here...

        Yeah but if they were fired over something like this I could see more lawsuits incoming from those parties.

          music*'s avatar - DiscoBallGlowing
          USN United States Navy
          Fresno, California
          United States
          Member #157851
          August 2, 2014
          3959 Posts
          Offline

          The California Lottery needs more employees like these four. 

           Secrecy in Government must be challenged with sunlight and courage. "Bringing embarrassment to your employer" is code for coverups. 

           The change will come this November at the ballot box.

           We must support Freedom of the Press. 

           "We are all in this together!" 

            Avatar
            Simpsonville
            United States
            Member #163184
            January 22, 2015
            2281 Posts
            Offline

            Steam coming out of my ears and couldn't read the whole article so am prejudiced in my thoughts.

             

            A 'ticketless' winner?  WTH is that all about.

             

            Too bad the whistleblowers didn't sue for more considering the 1/3 Attorney fee.

             

            Seems to me the Feds may look into this seemingly going down the toilet lottery, though not sure about this.  We'll see what comes of that up your dress Ma'am party when that comes to fruition.

              lejardin's avatar - Lottery-014.jpg

              United States
              Member #118605
              November 4, 2011
              1429 Posts
              Offline

              The California Lottery needs more employees like these four. 

               Secrecy in Government must be challenged with sunlight and courage. "Bringing embarrassment to your employer" is code for coverups. 

               The change will come this November at the ballot box.

               We must support Freedom of the Press. 

              Music, I was just going to say that exact statement "bringing embarrassment to your employer" stuck out like a sore thumb and brings to mind the story of having one head's under a woman's blouse rings true.  You are very right, ALL lotteries needs more employees like these in this story.  What is going on in other states we know nothing about? 

              Ticketless win?  I dont believe they have ever awarded a prize without a ticket?

                BuyLow's avatar - fd725949c52faf3bef0a9e377747408d -iphone-wallpaper-palm-trees.jpg
                Florida
                United States
                Member #61433
                May 22, 2008
                1212 Posts
                Offline

                California................That one word says it all  Crazy

                It truly is the land of 'Fruits and Nuts' Stooges

                  TheGameGrl's avatar - Lottery-012.jpg
                  A long and winding road
                  United States
                  Member #17083
                  June 10, 2005
                  6507 Posts
                  Offline

                  Transparency has yet to yield a false claim  maybe that's why most logical folks understand that anonymity has a backdoor for fiasco like this.

                  2500,2202,4441,6506,202, *13***

                    music*'s avatar - DiscoBallGlowing
                    USN United States Navy
                    Fresno, California
                    United States
                    Member #157851
                    August 2, 2014
                    3959 Posts
                    Offline

                    Transparency has yet to yield a false claim  maybe that's why most logical folks understand that anonymity has a backdoor for fiasco like this.

                    I Agree!  A case like Eddie Tipton would have never been prosecuted if he had anonymity. 

                     There are smarter crooks than Eddie was. 

                     "We are all in this together!"